The Inventors of Crayola Crayons: Binney & Smith

CrayolaBinney & Smith, now Crayola LLC, was an outgrowth of a chemical company that made pigments. The company started in 1864 in Peekskill, New York, and Joseph W. Binney was the owner. His son and a nephew took over when he retired, and they re-named the business Binney & Smith.

Peekskill Chemical Works sold their pigment product, “lampblack,” to foundries and to the cast-iron stove manufacturers that were located nearby. As the business grew and pigment was shipped elsewhere, the company used wax marking crayons to label the boxes. Later on, these wax crayons would be a main part of their business in the form of Crayola crayons.

Binney & Smith was not the first in the wax crayon market, but they gained a reputation for producing an excellent product that was entirely safe (chemical-free) for children to use.

Joseph Binney Passes Company to Family

When his son, Edwin Binney (1866-1934), finished his schooling in 1883, he joined his father’s company. One of Joseph’s nephews, C. Harold Smith (1860-1931) also joined the company around that time.

Binney & SmithIn 1885, Joseph Binney retired. Edwin and Harold were happy to take on the business and started using its new name, Binney & Smith.

Edwin Binney enjoyed working with the chemists on the behind-the-scenes side of the business. Smith had lived abroad at various times in his life so he was the logical person to travel to Europe and Asia looking for new pigments to sell. His most notable early addition was one he found in Newcastle in the United Kingdom. He bought American rights to what became known as “barn red,” a protective coat of paint that sold well to farmers.

New Pigment Developed

In the meantime, Edwin Binney was investigating new ways to expand their line at home. Some businesses were marketing a new pigment known as “carbon black,” which was a byproduct of the drilling for natural gas that was being done in western Pennsylvania.

Edwin Binney was very taken with the possibilities, and in 1892 he received a patent for an apparatus that permitted the mass manufacture of carbon black. Soon Binney & Smith became one of the major producers of the pigment.  (In 2011, Edwin Binney was honored posthumously by the National Inventors Hall of Fame in recognition for his invention.)

As a result of this business expansion, part of the company relocated to western Pennsylvania, near Easton. This location opened even more business opportunities. As the company processed the carbon black, Binney assigned his staff to work on ways to use the waste from the slate removal process. The result was an excellent, inexpensive slate pencil.

Slate Pencil Let Company Enter School Market

At the turn of the 20th century, school children each had their own slates (like small two-sided blackboards) since paper was expensive and not easy to come by. The students used slate pencils to write on these tablets, and the softer the pencil the better. (The marks from a slate pencil are very much like markings of chalk and can be easily wiped away using a cotton cloth–or even a sleeve.)

Binney & Smith chalkAs Binney & Smith became familiar with the school market, Smith began listening for what else teachers needed. Two requests came up again and again: chalk that didn’t produce a dusty mess, and inexpensive wax crayons children could use for artwork.

Binney’s staff in Pennsylvania continued experimenting. They found that if they added cement and talc (which came from a mine near Easton) to the slate waste, they had a dustless chalk. Eventually they developed what Binney named An-Du-Septic chalk, a dustless chalk.

The Binney & Smith chalk won a gold medal at the 1904 St. Louis World’s Fair. Teachers loved it and were delighted to do away with the chalk that left a residue on their fingers and clothes, not to mention dust in the air in the classroom.

Binney & Smith: Two Divisions

In the meantime, Binney & Smith expanded. The men decided to divide the company into two parts. The Pigment Division focused on paints and pigments for industrial use; the Crayola Division sold school products,

The pigment side of the business flourished first. In 1911, Binney & Smith received an order from B.F. Goodrich for an annual supply of one million pounds of carbon black. Tire companies saw that black tires looked better, but more important, the carbon black pigment greatly extended the life and durability of the tire.

Crayola Crayons Division Grows

The first wax crayons in the U.S. were imported from Europe, but by the 1880s, a few American companies were making them, too. Franklin Manufacturing in Rochester, New York, began with lumber and marking wax crayons, and by the 1880s, they expanded into the colored crayon market. Other companies, including Louis Prang (maker of early Christmas cards) and the Milton Bradley game company made wax crayons as well.

CrayolaIn addition, a good number of companies—including pencil companies that wanted to benefit from more sales—entered the wax crayon market before Binney & Smith. But because there were few national publications through which to advertise to the school market, each company found its own niche.

Edwin Binney assigned his chemists to work on ways to create a chemical-free crayon. Their current crayon, called “Stayonal (stay-on-all),” contained components that should not be handled regularly by school children.

By 1903 they were satisfied with their new product. Binney & Smith produced their first box of eight colorful crayons that year. Alice Binney, who was a former teacher, is credited with coming up with the Crayola name under which the crayons were released. (“Craie” means chalk in French and “ola” was a shortened form of the French word, “oléagineux,” which means oily.)

Crayola CrayonsAt first, the boxes were sold door-to-door for a nickel. Each box contained crayons in these colors: red, orange, yellow, green, blue, violet, brown, and black.  Each crayon was wrapped in paper and labeled as to color.

During the Depression, Binney & Smith hired farm families to hand-letter the papers and wrap the crayons. This provided work in an economic downturn, and over time, certain farms became known for their color specialty.

More and More Crayola Crayons

The Crayola division continued to add products. Over time, they added colored pencils and markers, and today there are many craft supplies made by the company.

The big seller, however, has always been crayons. And from the beginning (1903), they recognized the growing interest in art education. For that more refined market, they created the Rubens-Crayola crayon.

Crayola crayonsIn 1949, the box was expanded to hold 48 colors placed in a box with “stadium seating,” and in 1958 the classic 64-color box was introduced with a built-in sharpener.  In 1993, ninety-six colors were packaged into what they called the Big Box.

Over the years, the company added colors and has also responded to public pressure on certain names.  In 1962, they renamed the “flesh” crayon “peach” in recognition that there are many colors of flesh. The public also objected to “Indian red” though the company explained it was a reference a red dye in India. No matter, the public wanted a new name. Indian red was changed to chestnut (1999). Teachers also pointed out that “Prussian blue” was meaningless to children. The company of Prussia ceased to exist in 1947, so they renamed the blue midnight blue.

Involving the Public

Crayola has long recognized the importance of public opinion, and that is part of their success. In 1993, they ran a “Name the New Colors Contest.” Almost two million people entered. The oldest winner was an 89-year-old woman who submitted “purple mountain’s majesty” for a new shade of purple, and the youngest was 5, who submitted “razzmatazz” for the raspberry red crayon. To read all the new color names and their winners, click here.

Binney & SmithEight years later, the company wanted to know the most popular color. In 2001, they conducted the Crayola Color Census and the undisputed winner was the color blue; runners-up were various shades of blue.

The name Crayola is recognized by 99 percent of American households, and while crayons are still their primary product, they now sell many forms of craft products.  They also own manufacturing rights for Magic Markers and purchased Silly Putty in 1977.

In 1961 the company became publicly held, and in 1984, Binney & Smith became a wholly-owned subsidiary of Hallmark. In 2007, they changed their name to Crayola, LLC. As a well-known consumer company, Crayola has capitalized on their popularity. There are two museums, the Crayola Experience, dedicated to children and creativity. One is in downtown Easton, near the factory, the other is in Orlando, Florida.

How Are Crayola Crayons Made?

Of course, one question people always want to know is “how are crayons made?” Surprisingly, the method used today is similar to what was used long ago, but now it is automated.  The factory can produce 8500 crayons a minute.

There are some good YouTube videos put out by the company that tell the story of crayon production. The YouTube video I would recommend is not the most recent but this one is short and succinct.

Binney & Smith: The People

As the founders became wealthy, both made good use of their time and their money. Edwin Binney and his family split their time between Old Greenwich, Connecticut, and St. Lucie County, Florida, on the eastern coast near Boca Raton.

In both communities, he was well-respected. In Greenwich, there is a Binney Lane that runs right down to the water, and in St. Lucie County, he is credited with having had the vision to turn Fort Pierce into a port, now called Port Lucie.

C. Harold Smith stayed in the New York City area, and he was active in many civic organizations including the Union League Club of New York, the Transportation Club, the Upton Club, and the Hudson River Country Club.

I am grateful to crayon historian Ed Welter for his help in making this story as accurate as possible. He also has a Crayon Collecting website that tells the full story of the crayon industry. To read it, click here.

For another interesting story about a product sometimes used when doing home art projects, see Elmer’s Glue: The Surprising Story. 


Share with Others!

View sources >>

11 thoughts on “The Inventors of Crayola Crayons: Binney & Smith”

  1. Fascinating back story to one of the most potent memories from childhood. Whose heart didn’t thumpnwith excitement at one of the 64 crayon stadium packs? So gorgeous it was hard to actually use the crayons.

  2. I so agree with you. I remember that getting a box of the full 64 crayons was a favorite birthday present!

  3. The title of this is misleading. While Crayola created their own crayon, they didn’t invent the crayon. In fact, they were rather late in the market. By 1903 companies like Standard Crayon, Milton Bradley, Franklin and others had already been selling crayon for over 20 years. You did mention that in the article but downplayed it. In fact, everyone was trying to catch up with the market back then, it wasn’t just some crayons for artists. The big push over art in schools lead to the high demand. Also, you have perpetuated an inaccuracy that Crayola never seems to correct:. Ruben crayons weren’t developed in the 20s. They were there back at the beginning in 1903/04. I have a magazine with a picture of them from 1905.

  4. Dear Mr. Welter,
    Thank you so much for your thoughtful and knowledgeable comments. I truly appreciate people like you to take this type of time.
    I’m in meetings this week but next week I will pull out my research on this article. I’ll see where I may have gone wrong and make the corrections.
    Thanks very much!

  5. Pingback: The 1953 Murders of Gail and Paul Schultz - Defrosting Cold Cases

  6. Janice Bridgewater

    I have 4 tins of the collectors tins. 1. Collectors Color Limited Edition, which without having it right beside me is a Christmas one. It has a Bear Christmas ornament, 2. Is the 90th anniversary tin. 1903-1993. 3 Is a 1994 tin. 4 Is a 1992. None of these have been used. Does any of these have any value.

    Thank you for your time.

  7. Hi
    I don’t have any expertise in collectibles. I took a quick peek at ebay and Etsy and both seem to show there is a market for these things… but I don’t know what you were hoping for in value. You might check those two online places. If you sent a photo to one of the vendors, you might get some interest that way. They sound like fun things to have!

  8. Janice Bridgewater

    Hi, thank you for responding, not sure if I was looking for much of a value at this point, just thought I would send a email on here just to see if there was any info on these. Thanks for the info.

  9. It is fun to have those things… I have many where I love them but wonder, “then what?” Enjoy yours!

  10. Fascinating background story. Crayola crayons have been garbage for decades, and there is a thorough recording of the change in processes written by a woman who worked at the plant, in answer to a Quora question. She details it all, (and quit due to the changes after man yyears on the job), and I wish I had saved the comment. Wait – I found the post. Not wanting to breach intellectual property, nor Quora terms and conditions, the question in Quora was, “Why are Crayola crayons not coloring as good as they used to?” (My Google search words were – Crayola crayons are terrible). It is well-worth locating it. There is no reason to buy Crayola crayons.

    Thank you for the wealth of information, as well as the additional references and resources. This will be kept and referenced.

  11. Thank you for your comment. I’m sure others will be interested in the post from the woman who worked there.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Translate »
Scroll to Top